Why subscribe?
Subscribe to get full access to the newsletter and publication archives.
About The Deep Reader
AI can summarize a book in seconds. So why read at all?
Because a summary tells you what a text says. It cannot tell you whether to believe it, what it’s hiding, or what it means for you. That mental work—judgment—is the one thing machines can’t outsource back to us. And it’s exactly the work colleges are quietly failing to teach.
Professors report students arriving unable to read a full book. Universities are torn between banning AI and surrendering to it. Parents are asking what four years of tuition buys when answers are free. Everyone senses the same thing: the old model of college—transfer information, test recall—is dead. AI killed it. What survives is the thing AI can’t do.
The Deep Reader makes the case for that thing, and teaches it.
The method here is CERIC, five questions a deep reader asks of any text:
Claim — What is this text actually asserting?
Evidence — What supports it, and how good is that support?
Reasoning — Does the logic connecting evidence to claim hold?
Implications — If this is true, what follows?
Context — Who wrote this, when, and why?
CERIC is AI-proof by design: it’s a discipline of judgment you build through practice, not a knowledge a model can retrieve. The more powerful AI becomes, the more these five questions are worth.
What you’ll get here: Essays on the reading crisis in higher education and what college is for now; practical CERIC walkthroughs you can use in a classroom, with your kids, or on your own reading; and occasional close readings that show the method working on real texts, such as news, research, even AI output itself.
Who it’s for: Professors and education leaders rethinking their courses, parents and students deciding what college is worth, and any reader who suspects that skimming is making us easier to fool.
Reading below the surface is the skill the AI age selects as essential. Subscribe and learn to read deeply and critically like it matters—because it does.
Stay up-to-date
Never miss an update—every new post is sent directly to your email inbox. For a spam-free, ad-free reading experience, plus audio and community features, get the Substack app.
